How Safe Are Your Kids: Part 2

 MONTGOMERY COUNTY —While all three local school districts have enacted protocols in the last year to protect students and prevent shooting incidents, many of those precautions are being disregarded, according to a Red Oak Express investigation. 

During the investigation, schools in Red Oak, Villisca and Stanton all demonstrated assorted security breaches, including doors that should have been locked and open access to hallways and classrooms.

“Obviously, we aren’t following the procedures we have in place,” Red Oak Superintendent Terry Schmidt said after being informed the Red Oak High School graded the worst of the three schools tested by the Express. “Unless there is an accountability check like this, we don’t know how affective those procedures are.”

Red Oak’s high school underwent the three-tier assessment at about 12:15 p.m., Sept. 12. Schools were tested regarding how well they followed their protocols regarding accessibility, if a stranger wandering the halls was confronted by school personnel and what happened in that confrontation.

With one of two lunch sessions underway, the Red Oak High School is supposed to have the cafeteria doors open in addition to the main entrance doors on the east and west side of the building.

However, a reporter with the Express found an additional door about 20 feet from the cafeteria open, and upon entering, walked the high school hallways for five minutes.

Despite walking past numerous open classrooms, the reporter was not confronted by any school personnel he encountered. After the five minutes expired, the reporter left the school through the same entrance he entered and did encounter a janitor who said “hello.”

High School Principal Jedd Sherman confirmed in a follow-up interview the extra side door should be locked throughout the day.

“That is a failure on our part,” Sherman said. “That door shouldn’t have been unlocked, period.”

The door was not only unlocked during lunch, but after as well, as were the cafeteria doors, which are also supposed to be secured except during the open lunch period.

During the open lunch, juniors and seniors are allowed to leave the campus, a policy Schmidt said results in a “loosey-goosey” security situation.

“That’s a policy that has been in place since before I arrived in Red Oak,” Schmidt said. “And it certainly is one that creates some concerns.”

While the open lunch policy also predates Sherman, he said he believes it stems from a lack of space availability inside the cafeteria. The most feasible solution would be to expand to three lunch periods, one of which would have to start before 11 a.m.

Top of the Class

Southwest Valley’s middle school in Villisca easily outpaced Red Oak and Stanton in regards to the facility’s security and how faculty responded to a stranger walking the hallways.

Upon initial review, all of Villisca’s doors except for the main one were locked, as per district policy.

After entering the building and walking past the main office, the reporter proceeded to a nearby restroom.

When he exited the restroom, he was confronted by three school personnel asking if he needed help while requesting he check-in at the front office.

Junior High principal Lora Top said she has trained her staff to operate under a simple protocol: see something, say something.

“If you see something in the halls, you are to go up to somebody and say something,” she explained. “All visitors are supposed to have a badge and check in at the main building. If they don’t have that badge, we need to ask why.”

Top personally demonstrated her school’s diligence to security when after answering questions about her school’s security, she telephoned the Express office to verify the reporter was working for the newspaper.

“We know most of the people who work for the Express and we didn’t recognize him,” she explained. “We just wanted to make sure everything was on the up and up.”

Glenwood Opinion-Tribune Associate Editor Joel Stevens, who also serves as Regional Sports Editor for Southwest Iowa Publishing which includes the Express, was the reporter conducting the security assessment. He was selected with the hopes school personnel wouldn’t recognize him and thus, treat him as they would any other stranger and not as a media representative.

While Top and her staff at Southwest Valley earned high marks for their quick response and taking the extra step to verify Stevens’ credentials, there were still a couple glaring weaknesses in the building’s security.

Locked originally, a door to a storage room was found propped open when Stevens was leaving the building. Entrance was made into the storage room, which was unoccupied for several minutes. The storage room, which doubles as a weight room, does include access to the rest of the building.

While the door was eventually shut and locked, Top concedes it should never have been left open and unsecured.

Top also was personally guilty of a second discrepancy with district policy regarding security protocols. Four days after the security review, superintendent Willie Stone maintained there were signs at all doors requesting visitors to check-in at the main office.

There were no signs at any door.

“We had paper signs up in the windows last year and I took them down after the last day of school,” Top said. “Once I get off the phone here, I will go put those signs back up like I should have before school started.”

Top said she has a personal stake in school security beyond the obvious. Her niece was hiding in the school library during the Columbine shooting.

“I do know how it affects an entire family,” Top said. “I remember vividly the day of the Columbine shooting and trying to get in touch with my niece and nephew. It was nerve-wracking.”

Stanton Vacancy

With signs at every door requesting visitors to check-in at the front office and a policy of having only two doors open, Stevens entered one of the main office doors.

However, when he walked in the high school, no one was in the office.

After walking by the office, Stevens again walked the halls passing several open classrooms before going to the restroom.

Upon leaving the restroom and heading back out the exit, he walked past the previously empty main office. This time though, someone was there and approached Stevens, asking if he needed help. He proceeded to ask for the building principal, who was unavailable, and proceeded to leave.

Dean of Students Kevin Blunt was pleased to learn the secretary confronted Stevens, which was a point of emphasis with all school staff even before the Newtown shooting.

“It’s not fun to go up to people and say something, but that’s something that has to be done,” Blunt said.

He said desks were moved in the elementary office to better position staff so they could see who was coming and going through the doors.

Blunt also explained the high school office is sometimes manned by just one secretary which can cause lapses such as the one encountered the morning of Sept. 12.

“She could have been on a bathroom break or in another office,” he said. “It’s a gap you try to stay away from but there are times when that happens.”

Stanton’s only other security breach was an open garage door on the north side of the building. The door was observed open for several minutes with no one walking around inside or outside of the entrance.

Blunt said this door is typically closed, but had been broken previous to the Sept. 12 visit and has since been repaired.

“It’s fixed now but we need to make sure it is in fact closed at all times,” he said.

Improvements Needed

After being informed of the security issues at their respective schools, administrators agreed improvements are needed, including technological advances, better training and enforcing policies already in place.

“We probably haven’t hit people over the head enough that if you see a stranger, what are you going to do,” Sherman admitted. “That’s something we need to talk about more.”

Schmidt would also like to see some immediate improvements in terms of access to the Red Oak district’s buildings.

“I’d like to have every door secured so you can’t get in the building without a pass key,” Schmidt said. “That is the best short-term key to improve your security and it’s not a killer budget-wise either.”

Schmidt estimates the cost to install a pass key system at $10-15,000 per door.

Top stressed the importance of additional training for her staff, including the nationally recognized ALICE training.

Training strategies have changed a lot in recent years, Top said.

“Now they tell you to confront the person,” she said. “It used to be hide your kids and get them to safety. Now, its get the kids out the window or wherever they need to go and confront the gunman. I can see how that can save some people by keeping the gunman occupied.”

Southwest Valley will also be receiving video cameras and a buzz-in entry system for the main door.

Blunt agreed with Schmidt that a key-card access system would be ideal and that the Stanton board has discussed pursuing the purchase of one. However, no commitment has been made.

In the meantime, Blunt said he will continue to focus on training his staff and students to be prepared for the worst. Next week, the district will be conducting tests to respond to a possible intruder.

“It’s a situation you don’t want to have to think about but you have to be prepared for regardless,” Blunt said. “We can’t act like this will never happen here. We have to be ready.”

Editor’s note: This is part two of a two part series on school security. Part one detailed the specific policies in place at the area schools and ran in the Sept. 17 newspaper. The story can be viewed online here.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here