On the Side| Brad Hicks
Over-reaction generally reveals the absence of a rational thought, or minimally, a disingenuous one.
A news report earlier this month said the Iowa Department of Transportation plans to close DOT garages and state-operated driver’s license stations in Spencer and Carroll due to a $4.85 million budget cut in the last legislative session.
That report was followed by a press release from Iowa AFSCME Council 61 President Danny Homan, who said, “The closure of two driver’s license stations and six rural maintenance garages are a case of cause and effect. The cause is Iowa House Republicans, namely Majority Leader Chris Hagenow and Speaker Linda Upmeyer, attempting to entirely gut the Department of Transportation’s salary budget, later passing only half of what their own governor proposed.”
He also added, “For residents of Clay County, the nearest DOT driver’s license offices are in Sioux City, Fort Dodge, or Mason City, and for residents of Carroll County, they are in Fort Dodge or Ames.”
OK.
Let’s talk about that budget cut.
Republican Gov. Terry Branstad asked the Legislature for a $9.7 million increase in funding for the DOT to pay for increases for collective bargaining agreements, merit pay increases and state employee insurance contracts. That’s what the DOT requested, too. The Senate Democratic majority was on board, but the Republican House majority balked, arguing that it had given the DOT a 10-cent-a-gallon gas tax to be used for road and bridge improvements.
About that cut
First, the cut really wasn’t a cut. The $4.85 million is half of the requested $9.7 million increase, and that’s what lawmakers decided to do before going home. So, there was a $4.85 million increase included in a $373 million state transportation bill, which is 1.3 percent. Let’s at least call something what it is – a lower increase than requested. It’s disingenuous to do otherwise.
Gas tax money use
Second, when the gas tax was passed, the idea was to allocate the money to repairs and construction.
Republicans finally came on board with that, though for a long time it appeared they would rather spend their money on vehicle suspension repairs rather than fuel. Regardless, they didn’t want the money going toward salaries and benefits.
Rep. Dan Huseman, R-Aurelia, told reporters he didn’t doubt that additional gas tax money is being spent on roads and bridges, but that the timing of the request for more money for salaries wasn’t good. “I think it was a little bit arrogant,” he added.
It’s pretty disingenuous for the GOP leaders to argue the DOT got its money in the gas tax hike when they were opposed to giving any of that for general operations. And it’s disingenuous to call a request for a pay increase ‘arrogant’ in light of the gas tax passage when there was no intent to have salaries come from the gas tax.
“Gut” the budget
Third, it certainly doesn’t appear that Republicans were “attempting to entirely gut the Department of Transportation’s salary budget,” as alleged by the AFSCME leader.
As a person who is in charge of negotiating good deals for government employees, and trying to keep government employees working to ensure the future of the union, it’s his job to loudly state a case. He did his job. However, it’s highly unlikely this less-than-requested increase will result in the DOT salary budget being entirely gutted. The approved budget was an increase, for goodness sake.
That’s disingenuous. It’s likely there still will be DOT workers employed to do their good work.
License stations
Fourth, while it’s too bad state-run driver’s license stations in Clay County (Spencer) and Carroll County (Carroll) will close, the reality is the state long ago pulled its driver’s license stations from many Iowa counties, and yet, people in those counties still get their licenses at county treasurer’s offices. Are we to believe folks in Carroll and Clay counties won’t step to the plate and do what other counties have done by putting those services in their courthouses?
Even if they don’t, which would be shocking, every single county surrounding Clay and Carroll counties offers driver’s license services at the county treasurer’s office. Some of them offer complete services, such as CDL and motorcycle testing. It’s a disingenuous statement to say people will have to drive hours to Sioux City, Fort Dodge, Ames or Mason City. They won’t. AFSCME just wanted to keep the state jobs.
Snow removal
Finally, the reduction in the number of DOT garages could be a big deal, depending upon the locations eliminated. Snow removal is vital in Iowa, and the loss of the six garages might slow the process of getting roads plowed, which creates potential safety problems. I would hope the brainpower at the DOT would take it as a challenge and develop a logical solution. Perhaps, at the end, it will be the DOT that comes of out this looking like the people with a rational train of thought.
Brad Hicks is the Editor/Publisher of the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
